Does hg mv a bar/ discard a's history?
Matthias Luedtke
matthias-luedtke at gmx.de
Mon Jul 16 20:35:36 UTC 2007
Hi all,
first, I owe you a big 'thank you'! From what I've seen so far,
Mercurial is a damn nice piece of software. I hope you can explain to a
newbie what's going on here:
When I create a new repository and add two files
hg init foo
cd foo/
echo a > a
mkdir bar
echo b > bar/b
hg add a bar/b
hg commit -m 'Added two lovely files, a and bar/b'
and then do a
hg log a
it yields a's history as expected, like
changeset: 0:4b105d266186
user: Matthias Luedtke <email at matthias-luedtke.de>
date: Mon Jul 16 22:14:06 2007 +0200
summary: Added two lovely files, a and bar/b
However, when I move a to bar/
hg mv a bar/
hg commit -m 'Moved a to bar/'
and fetch a's history at its new place with
hg log bar/a
it just yields
changeset: 1:2128094e05a1
tag: tip
user: Matthias Luedtke <email at matthias-luedtke.de>
date: Mon Jul 16 22:15:10 2007 +0200
summary: Moved a to bar/
without a's first occurence in revision 0. I had expected something like
changeset: 1:2128094e05a1
tag: tip
user: Matthias Luedtke <email at matthias-luedtke.de>
date: Mon Jul 16 22:15:10 2007 +0200
summary: Moved a to bar/
changeset: 0:4b105d266186
user: Matthias Luedtke <email at matthias-luedtke.de>
date: Mon Jul 16 22:14:06 2007 +0200
summary: Added two lovely files, a and bar/b
as I am directly arriving from Subversion Plaza where they keep a files'
history across renames and moves.
Am I doing something wrong here? Who stole the history?
Or is this behaviour desired in the shiny world of distributed SCMs?
Cheers,
mat
More information about the Mercurial
mailing list